Winning the race

SEO Campaigns and the Ever Essential Benchmark

If your SEO campaign isn't working as expected, don't throw the baby out with the bath water. Learn how benchmarks can help you make a good campaign better.

We’ve all been there. You have this sweet SEO campaign planned out to the nth degree. You’ve put it into motion. You’re sure it’s going to:

  • Increase your traffic
  • Boost your ranking
  • Boost your ROI (Return on Investment)

Problem: After three months, your ROI is still a sinking ship. Your ranking seems to have a severe lack of motivation; it hasn’t even tried to move. Worse yet, your visitors have the attention spans of guppies, staying only long enough for the site to load – if you have visitors at all.

Let me repeat myself “one more time again”. We’ve all been there. Yes, even the SEO professionals get it wrong… well, occasionally.

See, SEO has this undefined human element. Yes, computer programs can do some of the grunt work for you, but eventually you cross a line where you have to actively make a decision. At some point, you have to decide whether you’re going to choose keyword A or keyword B, and then jump down the rabbit hole. Eventually, you, the human, have to act.

I believe the largest difference between the SEO professionals and the layperson is how you act. When it comes down to the wire and you see the SEO campaign you spent so much time on isn’t working, what do you do?

  • The Layperson: In my experience, I’ve noticed that most laypeople tend to have a “shove all” approach. If the SEO campaign isn’t working, shove all you can at the site and see if it helps. Either that or they toss the campaign and start over. Sort of like tossing out the baby with the bath water (I’m full of clichés today).
  • The SEO Professional: The professionals seem to take a sort of laid-back approach. First, there’s an unsurprised, yet thoughtful, “huh…” We immediately know we missed something somewhere along the way. Rather than toss out the campaign and start over, we turn into perfectionist naggers, nitpicking at every detail of the SEO campaign. Our job now is to find out what part of the campaign isn’t working as expected.

How do we do that? With the Three T’s of Optimization, of course. We track, tweak and test the campaign. Notice that I started with “track”. You, on the other hand, need to start with a part of any SEO campaign commonly missed by the layperson: the benchmarks.

You have to start with where you are and add where you’re going:

“My site is currently ranking 47 on Google for Keyword A. I want to see position 1 -4 for Keyword A within six months. To do this I will…”

Decide what methods you’re going to use to reach your goals. Then, write down the metrics that will be affected by those methods. For instance, if you’re going to use link building as one of your methods, you need to know how many, and what kind of, sites are linking to yours – before you start your campaign.

So – benchmarks. Don’t forget them.

As your campaign goes on, track the changes in those benchmarks on a regular basis. If your analytics program shows you a new site referring traffic to yours, you want to make a notation. If your search engine traffic goes up, you want to make a notation. If you post an article, write a blog, change a meta tag… you want to make a notation.

When things change, in other words, it’s a sign that your pen needs to visit the notepad. Mark it. Write it down. Highlight it. If things go wrong you’ll then have a recorded history of changes, making it that much easier to figure out where it went wrong. If you know the “where”, it’ll be easier to figure out “what” and “why”.

Comparing After the Fact

Maybe you didn’t think about the benchmarks. With most web analytic programs, you’re given the ability to compare the past with the present. For example, you can compare the month before you started your SEO campaign with the current month.

In this way, you can find out if your keyword reach (how many keywords, relevance of keywords, traffic coming in from them) has changed. You might find that targeted Keyword A is bringing less traffic than before, while you now have two more untargeted keywords bringing a few visits each.

While it’s not as comprehensive as a benchmark report, it’ll do in a pinch. Any kind of comparison can give you enough information to go on.

A final note: don’t assume you know what’s wrong based on information from one metric. Before you change anything, look at the whole picture. Some things, such as search engine changes like Google Instant, Penguin, Panda or pretty much anything Google for that matter, are beyond your control. A serious change in algorithms can derail a whole campaign – or it can mean a longer time span before your SEO campaign makes an impact.

Today's Author


Interested in Guest Posting?
Read our guest posting guidelines.

3 Responses

  1. In order to win the race, you need to know where you are going. SEO is a game, a race if you will, and it is important to know who is in front and how to get in front of them. This post is spot on. Benchmarking is a way to have a plan and know what needs to be done.

  2. Track, tweak, and testing is definitely effective for reviving a SEO campaign that is not doing as good as you would hope. I totally agree with you that some search engines have almost a human like characteristic, because they can change up so frequently and quickly. What has worked on your previous two campaigns isn’t a guarantee that the same thing will work on your next SEO campaign. This is why I feel it is important to have a good grasp on the SEO fundamentals so you know numerous SEO methods you can use to rank your site effectively.

  3. This is very well written. In my experience one of the elements of success on line and off line is giving value. When I’m involved in community service I get leads from my website. When I just work on my website without giving value on or off line, I get few or no leads.

    Website: Auto Accident Attorneys Utah

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

As Seen In

Hello there! Please read to understand how we handle your privacy.

This website uses tracking cookies to help us understand how you use the site and improve upon your experience. We do not share any information collected – either personal or anonymous – with any other parties, with the exception of the reporting programs we use in conjunction with those cookies. By continuing to use this site, you agree to the use of these cookies. If you do not agree, please close the site.