The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords?

by on March 8, 2012

Early in the morning on March 6, 2012, the news poured into the online world from MSNBC.com’s Red Tape section. Government agencies and colleges demand applicants’ Facebook passwords, the headline reads. It seems that SOPA and PIPA aren’t enough; it seems the social arena is one area the government, colleges and employers just can’t leave alone.

Is Your Privacy At Risk?

For years, we’ve warned individuals to guard their social accounts closely. “Employers are including social networks as part of the employer screening process,” we’ve cautioned. “Be very careful what you put on there. Be very careful what you allow your children to put on there. Explain to your kids the necessity of managing their social networks for the future job market.”

We’ve also given wider warnings that add up to, “If you don’t want something exposed to a broad online audience, don’t put it online. Online privacy is ethereal; it doesn’t really exist.”

Of course, our advice has always been based on the idea that employers could only see what you allowed to be seen by the world (unless your friends shared it with a wider audience). In other words, a locked down account won’t tell potential employers much. They could search until the sun goes down, and still only find what you allow public.

According to the MSNBC article, active social monitoring by government employers, college officials and businesses in the public sector has stepped up a huge notch. It’s no longer enough to be able to view your public conversations. They want to be in on your private conversations, too.

Privacy, Please.

MSNBC reports that job seekers for Maryland Department of Corrections have been required to log in and let an employer watch over their shoulders as they clicked through what had previously been considered private. Oh sure, it’s voluntary (hint, hint, nudge, nudge).

As shocking as this seems, the flagrant violation of privacy has been worse. As early as 2008, 22% of 31,000 surveyed employers said they used social networks for candidate evaluation, while 9% planned to use them.

Privacy

In 2009, the Wall Street Journal blogged about the city of Bozeman, Montana, which, for three years, had required municipal job applicants to turn over their social account login details. According to the WSJ blog, the city’s job applicant release form asked for “any and all current personal or business websites, web pages or memberships on any Internet-based chat rooms, social clubs or forums, to include, but not limited to: Facebook, Google, Yahoo, YouTube.com, etc.”

It wasn’t until a local news station reported on the requirement and outrage ensued that Bozeman put the policy on hold. However, the city stated that, while they may no longer require login information, they may still require individuals to “friend” a city official, so what was posted could still be seen.

In a California case around the same time, a college student wrote an ode about her home town and posted in on MySpace. The California Appellate Court ruled that, because the ode was posted on MySpace, the subsequent reposting of the ode to the local newspaper by a high school teacher wasn’t an invasion of privacy.

In 2010, Maryland’s Department of Public Safety and Correctional Services began the same practice of asking for the voluntary divulging of social media log in information. Again, the practice was voluntary. According to the department, whether the applicant agreed or not wasn’t taken into account at all.

Uh huh. Can you see it? “We want you to hand over your log in information so we can dig through your personal information, but, you know, we won’t hold it against you if you say no.” Sure.

When the ACLU found out, they sent the Maryland DOC a nicely worded letter, which stated, among other things, that the DOC’s “demand for login information is equivalent to demands that they produce all of their private correspondence and photographs for review, or permit the government to listen in on their personal telephone calls, as a condition of employment.” It was only then that the DOC suspended the practice, pending administrative review.

What’s Good for the Goose is Good for the Gander? Colleges Snag Control.

Goose or Gander?

This might be understandable for a government job – maybe. After all, the higher up the food chain you go in government positions, the more problems can arise if you’re secretly a gang member, spy, or have a past as a terrorist. When applying for government jobs, there’s somewhat of an understanding that you’re exposing your lives to the agency you’re to which you’re applying.

However, while government jobs may be one thing, what about colleges? According to a February 2011 article on Time.com, a survey reported that 82% of admissions officers used Facebook to recruit. Not a big deal, right? It’s just recruiting.

However, a more recent survey, as reported by SFGate.com, points to a bigger issue. About a quarter of scholarship providers who responded to the survey said they use online sources, including Facebook, to screen college scholarship finalists.

This takes us all back to the MSNBC.com article, which shares a tidbit of the University of North Carolina’s recently updated handbook:

“‘Each team must identify at least one coach or administrator who is responsible for having access to and regularly monitoring the content of team members’ social networking sites and postings,’ it reads. ‘The athletics department also reserves the right to have other staff members monitor athletes’ posts.’”

Isn’t this going a bit far? Isn’t this, just like a request for passwords, an invasion of privacy? Believe it or not, it can reasonably be argued that it isn’t.

No Real Right to Privacy

No Real Right To Privacy

That’s right. The invasion of privacy is seldom actually addressed in the U.S. Constitution. The First, Third, Fourth, Fifth , Ninth and Fourteenth Amendments, most often cited as “right of privacy“, only account for certain privates rights. They aren’t, as many people assume, a blanket set:

  • 1st Amendment (Privacy of Beliefs): The right to privacy of beliefs, including religion, freedom of speech, freedom of assembly and freedom to petition the government
  • 3rd Amendment (Privacy of Home): No soldier can force a home owner to allow them to live there, whether in peace or in war, unless it’s done in a manner prescribed by law
  • 4th Amendment (Privacy of Person and Possessions): The right to be secure in your person, house, papers and effects against unreasonable searches and seizures
  • 5th Amendment (Privilege Against Self Incrimination): The right to remain silent and not incriminate yourself
  • 9th Amendment (Broad statement of rights): The enumeration of certain rights shouldn’t be construed as denying or disparaging other rights
  • 14th Amendment (Liberty Clause): No state can deprive a person of life, liberty or property without due process

 

The closest amendment to deal with the Facebook issue is the 4th Amendment, but it still has a fair amount of maneuvering room. For example, are your Facebook posts considered papers or effects? Can requiring a college student to “friend” a college counselor be construed as unreasonable search and seizure? –And, while your Facebook posts may very well keep you from a scholarship or employment, can they be considered incriminating evidence?

Social Media on the Horizon

All of this raises serious questions, the number one being: “Should a serious college or job applicant drop out of the social arena all together?” As well, the news hit the wires less than six months after Jobvite released a November 2011 survey and infograph (The State of Social Recruiting in 2011). The survey states that 89% of U.S. companies will use social recruiting, while 82% of job seekers use social networks.

The real answer may be, “yes” and “no”. In other words:

  • Yes – use social networks and build an online reputation
  • No – if you wouldn’t want your grandma or mother to see what you’re posting, don’t post it

Quite simply, the recent developments in social media monitoring by the government, employers and colleges demands you start taking your social account use seriously. If you thought Google pulling all their privacy policies together into one was bad step in the wrong direction, you ain’t seen nothin’ yet.



{ 5 comments… read them below or add one }

Richard Thompson February 4, 2014 at 1:21 pm

I agree with Liz, demanding login information is a complete breach of privacy. However, screening your future employees’ social media profiles is not only a smart thing to do, it’s also something employers should do. You can find out a great deal about how professional and respectful someone is by their social media profiles.

Reply

Kriste Cicero September 3, 2012 at 3:26 am

This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I enjoy seeing websites that understand the value of providing a prime resource for free. I truly loved reading your post. Thanks!

Reply

Glenn Ferrell March 11, 2012 at 6:13 am

Fascinating post – made me think. Another way to look at the Amendments listed above is:

1) We have the right to conceal our stupidity, or to make it widely known.
3) Soldiers can move into my house if it is prescribed by law.
4) It’s okay for folks to search my person, house, papers and effects, if that search is “reasonable.”
5) We have the right to remain silent but certainly no guarantee that what we say won’t be forever available through search engines.
14) Given enough due process, we’re royally screwed.

Reply

Level343 March 13, 2012 at 2:14 pm

lol Number 14 sounds about right, Glenn – love the way you broke those amendments down into plain terms anyone can understand and be afraid of. :D

Reply

Liz March 10, 2012 at 11:53 am

Using social media to screen candidates is sensible. Demanding their logins is terrible.

Regardless, only ever posting granny and boss safe posts is important advice for everyone.

Reply

Comment Guidelines: The comment form must be filled in with an actual name. This blog is actively moderated, and comments with keyword names will be deleted. We reserve the right to edit or delete any comments using keywords, spam or splog-like URLs, or suspicious information in the comment form.


Linking Guidelines: We welcome links that encourage and continue conversation, such as links to related blog pages. If you've written about (or read elsewhere) the article topic and feel the piece would enhance ours, please, do share. Again, this blog is actively moderated. If we come across a link we don't feel enhances the conversation, we'll simply unlink it.

Leave a Comment

{ 70 trackbacks }

  • Gabriella Sannino

    The American Constitution does NOT protect your rights...I had no idea | The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords?| http://t.co/Cmk11i0c

  • Jahnelle Pittman

    There's no "Right" to #Privacy in Constitution - Businesses, colleges taking advantage in #social media http://t.co/JEogSc7c via @level343

  • Massimo/Gabriella

    RT @jrpittman: There's no "Right" to #Privacy in Constitution - Businesses, colleges taking advantage in #social media http://t.co/svcQWclL

  • Level-343 Team

    The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords?| http://t.co/IcOrFJPw The American Constitution does NOT protect your rights...I had no idea

  • thomas clifford

    RT @SEOCopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/QkR2AdaD

  • Danielle Smith

    RT @SEOCopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/LtchNF6z

  • 【ツ】Ron Callari

    RT @SEOCopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/R3o5WjwR

  • iggy pintado

    RT @SEOCopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/j9GAX8PG

  • Mary E Haight

    RT @SEOCopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/j9GAX8PG

  • Massimo/Gabriella

    RT @SEOCopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/svcQWclL

  • John Lusher 

    RT @SEOcopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/Zl7XxM6t

  • Misty Belardo 

    RT @SEOCopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/rh172JEf

  • Alejandro Tortolini

    RT @mistygirlph: RT @SEOcopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #privacidad http://t.co/AZDIaBYU

  • Julia Rosien

    RT @SEOCopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/yt99drCj

  • Alex Greenwood

    RT @SEOCopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/yOoxeBBi

  • bkmacdaddy designs

    RT @SEOCopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/lfJidnvE

  • purplehayz

    RT @SEOcopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/sN00QZoI

  • SarahRobinson

    RT @SEOCopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/pxFWBDZD

  • TJ McCue

    RT @SEOCopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/3RJTcPWp >not giving mine out!

  • Joseph Cannizzaro

    RT @SarahRobinson: RT @SEOCopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/fMAZ8q18

  • Jeff Jacobs

    RT @SEOCopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/e8NHkN2P

  • Michelle Harris

    RT @SEOCopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/cyQ44UiO

  • Level-343 Team

    For years, we’ve warned individuals to guard their social accounts. http://t.co/QxwaD3yt | Our latest post, a must read if you're online.

  • Bear Files

    RT @SEOCopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/XZ8zXEPf

  • Francisco Rosales

    RT @SEOcopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/HR2YKKIA

  • Steve Akins

    RT @SEOCopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/wxYLgz5R

  • Aaron Lee

    RT @SEOCopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/mCmuXn5D

  • Tony Hastings

    RT @SEOCopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/96o8T7Qr

  • Dawn Riley

    RT @SEOCopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/XQ74cv5a

  • Michelle Mangen

    RT @SEOCopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/xEI0MmIw

  • SNC Geek On Call

    RT @SEOcopy The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? http://t.co/KPe9iqCo

  • Kathy Meyer 

    RT @SEOCopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/UzQiV0QI

  • Jahnelle Pittman

    The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords?: Early in the morning on March 6, 2012, the news poure... http://t.co/UfyR0h25 via @level343

  • cinnamon_carter

    RT @AskAaronLee: RT @SEOcopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/v8bnx9Tt

  • Loreto Bello Gude

    The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/IAyneRY9 RT @SEOcopy @AskAaronLee @cinnamon_carter

  • David Harry

    RT @SEOcopy The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? http://t.co/zS8jTHrj

  • SEOTweets.me

    The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? http://t.co/953QtUc9 (via @SEOcopy)

  • Ana Hoffman

    The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? http://t.co/LhAWFoRP via @SEOCopy

  • Joe Kelly

    RT @SEOCopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/UzQiV0QI

  • Bonnie Burns

    RT @SEOcopy The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? http://t.co/KPe9iqCo

  • Bonnie Burns

    RT @searchcentral: RT @SEOcopy The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? http://t.co/t5iSmQUQ

  • Klaus Junginger

    RT @Burnsie_SEO: RT @searchcentral: RT @SEOcopy The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? http://t.co/WwJRXzKQ // R-E-L-E-V-AN-T .

  • Marty McPadden 

    RT @SEOCopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/aQxcUhHi

  • A.R.Karthick

    The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? http://t.co/7n8SND48 | #Facebook #ORM #SocialMedia RT @SEOCopy

  • The Dude Dean

    RT @SEOCopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/5jWRrwO4

  • TECHPLUGGED

    The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? http://t.co/p6dzTevY via @SEOcopy

  • Marc Custers

    The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? - http://t.co/rx5cRa33 - @level343 RT @SEOCopy @2cre8 #Facebook #SocialMedia

  • Laura Crest

    Reading: "The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords?"( http://t.co/l2soI26i )

  • pagan

    The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? | http://t.co/K1loQiXy #Facebook #SM rt @level343 SEOCopy @2cre8 @marccusters

  • Michele Lorito-Chase

    RT @SEOCopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/wKjzW4ii

  • Bob Mcintire

    The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? | http://t.co/K1loQiXy #Facebook #SM rt @level343 SEOCopy @2cre8 @marccusters

  • Peggy Fitzpatrick

    The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? http://t.co/RZQyywv3 via @SEOcopy

  • Ching Ya

    The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? http://t.co/ol0RNSKo via @SEOCopy #Facebook #ORM #Social Media

  • Roseli A. Bakar

    The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? http://t.co/ol0RNSKo via @SEOCopy #Facebook #ORM #Social Media

  • Glenn Ferrell

    The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #privacy #Facebook #ORM #reputation management RT @level343: http://t.co/q4BO91lp

  • Wasim Ismail

    The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #reputation management #Social media #Social http://t.co/xBmfBqT3 RT @Level343

  • Shelly Kramer

    RT @SEOCopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/pvA1yHOV

  • Erica Friedman

    RT @SEOCopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/pvA1yHOV

  • Leigh_Andrews

    RT @SEOCopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/pvA1yHOV

  • Guilherme Carreri

    RT @SEOCopy: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM #Social Media http://t.co/pvA1yHOV

  • liver

    Would you give over your social media passwords for a job? http://t.co/pDIZTmrJ

  • Geek Woman

    Told ya so http://t.co/gByu6bAA

  • Jive Loustaunau

    Told ya so http://t.co/4Lit0CzQ

  • Think First Web

    The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? http://t.co/BWqKe5xr

  • Ali Williams

    The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? | Organic SEO / SMO for small business http://t.co/WNrn40MJ

  • Level-343 Team

    The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #Facebook #ORM http://t.co/GdYVR9WB

  • Massimo/Gabriella

    RT @glenn_ferrell: The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #privacy #Facebook #ORM #reputation management http://t.co/svcQWclL

  • Level-343 Team

    The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #ORM #reputation management #Social media #Social http://t.co/GdYVR9WB

  • Mary-Kay Massey

    The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? http://t.co/7TTB38vp #ORM #Socialmedia #Fact | It's happening everyday... crazy stuff

  • Level-343 Team

    The Right to Demand Your Social Passwords? #ORM #reputation management http://t.co/GdYVR9WB | Goodnight